Difference between revisions of "ReleaseStatus Minutes 2010-05-17 IRC log"

Revision as of 14:20, 17 May 2010

This page ignores the Wiki Contribution Guidelines. New pages should not do that. Please read the Guidelines and fix the page. At least: use categories provide links between pages so that your page is neither orphaned nor a dead-end page. keep drafts on your userpage see Help:Translating for nonenglish content Please note that it is possible that pages that are not following the guidelines will be deleted to avoid confusion. Feel free to remove this warning from the page when you have fixed it. (However, when the page is fixed this warning will be removed soon anyway). For more information just ask the people of the project: Communication IRC Communication

(15:00:02) Das Thema für #oooreleases ist: Release-Stauts-Meeting, every monday at 15:00 Hamburg Time (13:00 UTC in summer)
(15:00:07) ja_: Moin
(15:01:35) enoki: hi
(15:01:39) mdamboldt: Hi
(15:02:12) stefan_b: Hi
(15:02:16) gibi33: Hi
(15:02:28) mdamboldt: Status 3.2.1 release:
(15:02:41) mdamboldt: Possible stopper Issue 111636 has been raised on the mailing list. Detailed technical evaluation is in progress right now.
(15:02:47) IZBot: Presentation DEFECT NEW P3 The background become no color to white color http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=111636
(15:02:51) blauwal [~jr93709@nat/sun/x-bygyztqalngxkmdw] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:03:20) _rene_: I hoped we had that until now so we can decide :/
(15:04:02) mdamboldt: The issue has been introduced in one of the last three builds. OOO320m14 was ok.
(15:04:09) of_sun: Hi
(15:04:45) MechtiIde: mdamboldt, so you can reproduce the problem?
(15:04:48) _rene_: I mean, it was reported how long ago? seven hours ago if I count right...
(15:05:13) mdamboldt: Mechtilde: yes, I was able to do so. So is Wolfram Garten, too.
(15:05:23) mdamboldt: Currently Andre Fischer is looking into it.
(15:05:33) gibi33: and so do I on any new fresh document
(15:06:24) gibi33: but do we have to discuss whether eligible or not as a stopper?
(15:06:51) _rene_: we should, but as we have no info...
(15:07:24) rafaella [~Rafaella@nat/sun/x-yjffnainjwxwctrm] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:08:06) mdamboldt: _rene_: What do you mean by "no info"?
(15:08:43) _rene_: "Possible". "Detailed technical evaluation is in progress right now"
(15:10:12) mdamboldt: _rene_: Do you think it's a stopper? It's an easy to reproduce severe issue I think.
(15:10:13) gibi33: ok, I understand that's about technical analysis but what about its importance?
(15:11:05) gibi33: I vote to be a stopper even if there's no data loose it's unusable
(15:11:44) ml1: _rene_: "seven hours ago if I count right...", no it's 5 hours max, incl. lunch break
(15:12:40) _rene_: ah, yeah, 6
(15:12:42) mdamboldt: There is a workaround to use menu "Insert->duplicate page" instead of simple copy & paste via slide sorter for example. But I guess thats not a sufficient workaround.
(15:12:54) _rene_: (me errorneously counted in UTC)
(15:13:38) gibi33: mdamboldt: it happens also when you copy/paste the text frame instead of the entire slide
(15:14:35) mdamboldt: Additional I've heard rumors about another issue that the Dutch OOo installations set lacks dictionaries. I'm not aware of any Issue # so far.
(15:14:49) stefan_b: mdamboldt, see my answer: Works well.
(15:15:05) mdamboldt: stefan_b: Where to look?
(15:15:18) stefan_b: At my desk :-)
(15:15:31) stefan_b: Cor mailed this to dev@qa
(15:15:46) of_sun2 [~chatzilla@nat/sun/x-dfhaxrnqxtcjwzrm] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:16:14) stefan_b: mdamboldt, there was no issue for this.
(15:16:47) rafaella: stefan_b, so you checked the rc1 Linux?
(15:17:15) stefan_b: I checked with internal m17 builds on Win and Linux (rpm) I will re-verify with the download install sets.
(15:17:52) rafaella: stefan_b, yes, please on the same install sets Cor found the issue....
(15:19:26) stefan_b: Well, he did not tell wich one in his mail :-(
(15:19:36) of_sun: No information where cor found the issue.
(15:19:53) of_sun2 hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Client Quit).
(15:20:41) calc hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Quit: Coyote finally caught me).
(15:20:44) mdamboldt: Ok, so we need to look at the download set and one may ask Cor for additional details.
(15:20:57) calc [~calc@c-98-200-192-86.hsd1.tx.comcast.net] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:21:08) _rene_: and how is missing dictionaries a blocker? even if it is no.
(15:21:11) stefan_b: I will mail to him directly and track this down. I am currently downloading too.
(15:21:18) _rene_: correct, it is none. :)
(15:21:25) calc heißt jetzt Guest52217
(15:21:27) _rene_: people can easily install them
(15:21:37) stefan_b: As said, not a general problem. cor himself proposed that being NO stopper.
(15:22:50) rafaella: _rene_, I think that it would be show stopper if many languages are affected by this issue.
(15:23:06) _rene_: I don't.
(15:23:33) MechtiIde: this isn't a stopper IMO
(15:23:43) _rene_: IMHO OOO containing own versions of dicts other stuff also uses is a bug
(15:24:10) _rene_: that leads into the same dict being on HD at different places numerous times ;)
(15:27:14) mdamboldt: Regarding Issue 111636 I propose to wait for developer feedback on this issue. Sounds we need to do a RC2 build.
(15:27:19) IZBot: Presentation DEFECT NEW P3 The background become no color to white color http://qa.openoffice.org/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=111636
(15:28:01) Guest52217 heißt jetzt calc
(15:28:05) calc hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Changing host).
(15:28:05) calc [~calc@ubuntu/member/calc] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:30:52) ja_: mdamboldt: Is this decision taken so I have to withdraw my approvals on QATrack ?
(15:34:26) Fridrich: I would advocate not to rush this if that bug can be fixed
(15:35:17) Fridrich: it is not like it was RC20 and we are tired from RCs
(15:35:17) wope hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Ping timeout: 268 seconds).
(15:35:42) Fridrich: but 3.2.1 should be better then 3.2 and given the massive changes, better to be sure then sorry
(15:37:13) ***MechtiIde want also to know if she have to withdraw the bbuilds from qatrack
(15:37:21) wope_away [~wope@85-127-78-138.dynamic.xdsl-line.inode.at] hat den Raum betreten.
(15:37:22) wope_away heißt jetzt wope
(15:37:33) mdamboldt: So are people fine by following the corresponding issue or do we need a separate RSM tomorrow?
(15:38:03) _rene_: how should following the issue lead to a "yes/no"?
(15:38:20) ja_: Mechtilde: I've set the en-US builds back to "in qa"
(15:38:34) MechtiIde: we need a decision
(15:38:48) MechtiIde: do we get another RC?
(15:38:53) ml1: IMHO depends on what we will see in the issue from the dev team
(15:39:06) ml1: easy to fix --> RC2
(15:39:10) ml1: not easy --> ?
(15:39:37) Fridrich: I am for another RC and would be nice to know how much risk that another showstopper will pop up?
(15:39:54) mdamboldt: My understanding is yes it is a stopper. So I read gibi33.
(15:40:04) gibi33: +1
(15:40:23) Fridrich: +1
(15:40:55) MechtiIde: so we expect another RC this week and next monday is bank holiday in Germany so the next RSM we need another day next week
(15:40:58) blauwal: +1
(15:41:06) wope: +1
(15:41:45) enoki: +1
(15:42:12) mdamboldt: Mechtilde: The RSM will simply move by one day in my point of view. So next RSM is Tuesday 25th May 2010.
(15:42:54) MechtiIde: this is ok for me. At 15:00 Hamburg Time (13:00 UTC)?
(15:43:14) mdamboldt: Hopefully a fix will be available early this week so we can trigger RC2 (OOO320m18) by end of this week.
(15:43:31) mdamboldt: Mechtilde: Same time as on every Monday.
(15:43:53) MechtiIde: then it is for the record
(15:44:24) mdamboldt: Ok. Sounds thats all for 3.2.1 release for todays meeting.
(15:45:23) _rene_: mdamboldt: eh, no, that's nonsense
(15:45:44) _rene_: if a fix is available early this week, why a build *end* of the week? build immediately?
(15:46:17) mdamboldt: _rene_: QA and check whats fixed before you integrate anything in any state and make things even worth by accident?
(15:46:33) _rene_: mdamboldt: true.
(15:46:56) Fridrich: like in the 3.2 release cycle the master fix that fsck-ed up no l10 builds
(15:47:02) _rene_: mdamboldt: but still, let#s assume we have the fix tomorrow and get it QAed, staring the build end of the week doesn't make sense
(15:47:29) _rene_: then we'll have all the build only mid next week seeing how long the windows stuff needed
(15:47:35) _rene_: + 1 week waiting + ....
(15:47:51) mdamboldt: _rene_: As soon as I've more detailed infos from corresponding developer about side effects, etc. I will look for an earliest possible integration.
(15:47:55) Fridrich: let us take it as +1 from _rene_ them :)
(15:48:21) ja_: +1
(15:49:01) mdamboldt: Regarding 3.3 I like to give you all a short heads-up. Based on current 3.2.1 state I would roughly plan with a possible branch off for 3.3 end of June / beginning of July. Detailed planning should be part of our release meeting next week, so please prepare yourself for next meeting.
(15:51:44) MechtiIde: this also mean beginning of translation at begin of July?
(15:52:00) MechtiIde: and thee Beta Version at the same time?
(15:53:05) mdamboldt: Mechtilde: In the past turnarounds between translation handover/handback were not that fast. Let's outline details in next weeks meeting.
(15:54:14) mdamboldt: Anything else for todays meeting?
(15:54:16) stefan_b: About Dutch spellchecker: Checked both Win download sets (with/without JRE) and Linux RPM with JRE: All fine.
(15:54:26) mdamboldt: stefan_b: thanks
(15:54:46) stefan_b: Will wait for Cor to respond before investigating further.
(15:55:38) dtardon hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Quit: this parrot is dead).
(15:56:45) mdamboldt: bye
(15:57:11) stefan_b: Bye
(15:57:16) rafaella: bye
(15:57:20) rafaella hat den Raum verlassen (quit: Quit: Leaving).
(15:57:40) ml1: bye
(15:58:05) of_sun: bye